How to choose the best 5G system for the lab

How to choose the best 5G system for the lab

me:

do we have 5G full solutions just like free5G.org? I am looking for some solution like free5G.org to deploy it on my homelab.

Grok:

Yes, there are several open-source 5G core network solutions similar to Free5GC (which I assume you meant by "free5G.org," as it's a popular project at free5gc.org). Free5GC itself is a solid option—it's an Apache 2.0-licensed implementation of the 3GPP Release 15+ 5G core, using a service-based architecture with containerized deployment via Docker and Kubernetes, making it straightforward for homelab setups by cloning the GitHub repo and following their guides. Below, I'll outline some strong alternatives that provide full or near-full 5G core functionality, focusing on those suitable for personal or homelab deployment (e.g., on standard hardware with Docker/Kubernetes). These are based on community-recommended projects and can often be paired with simulators like UERANSIM for end-to-end testing without real radio hardware.

1. Open5GS

2. Magma

3. OpenAirInterface (OAI)

4. SD-Core

Complementary Tool: UERANSIM (for Testing)

For homelab deployment tips across these: Start with Docker on Ubuntu or similar, ensure you have at least 8GB RAM and a multi-core CPU for smooth operation. Many require a USRP or software-defined radio for full RAN, but simulators like UERANSIM can bypass that. Check community forums (e.g., Reddit's r/networking) for real-user setups, and always review the latest GitHub docs as projects evolve. If you provide more details on your hardware or specific needs (e.g., SA vs. NSA mode), I can refine recommendations.

me:

in my lab, i have 1 Dell PowerEdge T430 with 64 core CPU and 256 GB RAM and 10 TB storage and 6 NICs. along with these resources, i have L3 router and OPNsense firewall. and all of these would host 3 master and 1 work nodes and some VMs to manage the lab such as RootCA, monitoring system and so on. for this lab, which one or two of the mentioned solutions is/are more suggested?

 

Grok:

Based on your homelab setup—a powerful Dell PowerEdge T430 (64 cores, 256 GB RAM, 10 TB storage, 6 NICs) running a Kubernetes cluster with 3 master nodes and 1 worker node, plus VMs for ancillary services like RootCA and monitoring, alongside an L3 router and OPNsense firewall—the hardware far exceeds the minimum requirements for any of these open-source 5G core solutions (typically 8 GB RAM, 1-2 CPUs, and 10-160 GB storage per instance). This means resource constraints aren't a concern; focus instead on ease of deployment (especially with Kubernetes), stability, community support, and homelab-friendly features like WebUIs for configuration/monitoring.

From recent comparisons (as of 2025), I recommend Free5GC and Open5GS as the top one or two options for your setup. They're the most straightforward for homelab use, integrate well with Docker/Kubernetes, and align with private network testing without overcomplicating things. Here's why, with a quick comparison to the others:

Recommended: Free5GC (Top Pick for Simplicity)

Recommended: Open5GS (Strong Second for Performance/Features)

Why Not the Others (Quick Rationale)

Start with Free5GC for a quick win, then try Open5GS if you want richer features. Both pair well with your firewall/router for secure traffic and UERANSIM for no-hardware testing. If you hit issues (e.g., NIC binding), check Reddit r/homelab or project forums. Let me know more about your goals (e.g., VoNR focus) for finer tuning!